Gender Neutral Ground Combat Arms Roles - 7352 Words

Profoundly influenced by two post-9/11 protracted wars that highlighted the expanded role of women in combat, civilian leaders have opted to pursue a gender neutral military apparently on the grounds that integrating women in direct ground combat arms roles is both essential and prudent. Central to the rhetoric is that women are not only qualified, but that they bring a wealth of diverse talents that they should be able to apply across all disciplines within the Armed Forces and in turn, be afforded the opportunity to ascend to more senior ranks. However, policy makers are deliberately ignoring decades of medical research and evidence that strongly counter the logic of such a decision and brings into question their motives. The purpose of this paper is to synthesize and present the extensive body of evidence that exists counter to the rationality of pursuing a fully integrated, gender neutral military. This research paper uses a qualitative approach to argue that integrating wom en in the Marine Corps’ infantry will degrade readiness, deplete a talented pool of women from the total force, and impact the overall combat effectiveness of the Marine Corps. After presenting a brief background of how we arrived at the present date decision and debate, this paper will enumerate the impacts of physiological differences between genders. Next, the paper will then lay out the cumulative impacts that the difference in physical strength and endurance have on attrition and readinessShow MoreRelatedThe Civil Field Or Clerical Support1165 Words   |  5 Pagesis frowned upon if any gender is excluded from employment opportunities or types of jobs. Up until recent years, the military totally excluded women from certain combat jobs due to their gender. â€Å"For most of the history of the U.S. military women have only served in roles in the medical field or clerical support† (Barry,19). Some of this is due to the different physical abilities between genders; cost of logistics and military effectiveness. We should not make every combat arm Military OccupationalRead MorePolicy Introduction And Identification Of The Military Services And United States Special Operations Command1453 Words   |  6 PagesJanuary of 2013, the Department of Defense set aside the â€Å"1994 Direct Ground Combat Definition and Assignment Rule† (Carter, 2015). This takes all restrictions off women allowing all who meet the qualifications to hold a combat role in the military. The Armed Forces have opened over 110,000 positions to women and have set their standards. Anyone, who can meet operationally relevant and gender neutral standards, regardless of gender, should have the opportunity to serve in any position (Carter, 2015)Read MoreHuman Life And Broader Nature865 Words   |  4 PagesGender roles have always existed to some extent throughout history, and it has been a stepping stone of human life and broader nature. In the Greek society women were not allowed to impede in politics or any matter other than their household work, yet the goddess of marriage and birth, Hera, defies all of the rules. Hera’s jealousy, trickery, and temper creates unwanted havoc, thus making her a significant character in The Iliad. Hera is an exceedingly determined goddess and will go to any lengthsRead MoreWomen During Combat - Rough Draft1609 Words   |  7 Pages Women in Combat – Rough Draft January 24, 2013 Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta lifted the ban on women serving in combat. For years women have served with honor and distinction. When faced with combat and in an insurgency type of modern warfare, any soldier can potentially see combat. Realistically, there is a difference between experiencing combat on a convoy and going out day after day on combat patrols to perform search and destroy missions. Having served as a Marine Infantryman in AfghanistanRead MoreWomen During World War II1450 Words   |  6 Pageswomen have increasingly served, and continue to serve, with valor and integrity in the Unites States Armed Forces (Kamarack, 2015). Although women have successfully proved themselves in the military, they should be restricted from entering into direct combat because they are less physically fit than their male counterparts, create animosity on front lines, and undermine cohesion within a military unit. The integration of women into the armed forces has effectively progressed since the early days ofRead MoreEssay Women in Combat1323 Words   |  6 Pagesnine-to-five job but rather a calling. It is about being a part of the Profession of Arms. Airmen are warriors. The third verse of the Air Force Airman’s Creed states, â€Å"I am an American Airman, Guardian of Freedom and Justice, My Nation’s Sword and Shield, its Sentry and Avenger. I defend my country with my Life† (Huguley, 2009, p.1). The word â€Å"Airmen† is gender neutral in the creed; yet, women who want to serve in combat roles are still denied the privilege. Now is the time for the all military branchesRead MoreMilitary Women Should NOT Be Allowed in Combat Positions1666 Words   |  7 Pageskiller.nbsp; Do women fit any of these descriptions?nbsp; Should a woman be permitted to enter into combat situations?nbsp; Some argue that it is a womans right to be fighting along side other men.n bsp; Others agree that by not letting women in ground troops her rights are being taken away. A woman can be anything that she wants but when she tries to prove that she is just as good as a man in combat she could be putting herself in very dangerous situations that could effect her and her unit. Read MoreNew Deal And Social Security3151 Words   |  13 PagesSecurity Act was created. This act provided aid to dependent children, unemployment and disability insurance, and pensions for the elderly. An issue with this system was that it might seem like a welfare program rather than an insurance program. To combat this issue, the social security funds would be from payroll taxes from employers and workers. Younger generations would finance the fund and would benefit from the system once they turned 65. Although this was a much-needed system, especially afterRead MoreMasculinity in the Philippines12625 Words   |  51 Pagesirresistible, manner. As powerful, intrusive institutions, modem armies transformed cultures and shaped gender identities, fostering rhetoric and imagery whose influence has persisted long after colonial rule. Above all, these armies, colonial and national, propagated a culture, nay a cult of masculinity. Recent historical research has explored the ways that rising European states reconstructed gender roles to support military mobilization. To prepare males for military service, European nations constructedRead MoreAlternative Dispute Resolution Mechanism21967 Words   |  88 PagesInternational Negotiation 3.7. Negotiations Over Water 3.7.1. International Water Negotiations/Conflicts 3.7.2. Intra-national Water Negotiations/Disputes 3.8. Treaties 4. Mediation 4.1. The Advantages of Mediation 4.2. Positive Results of Mediation 4.3. The Role of the Mediator 4.4. Skills and Tools of a Good Mediator 4.5. The Problems that the Mediator Attempts to Resolve 4.6. Techniques and Strategies 4.7. Models and Approaches to Mediation 4.8. Controversial Issues in Mediation 4.9. Psychological Issues